Understanding the FTC’s Click to Cancel Rule: Key Implications for B2B Relationships
Disclaimer: The information provided does not constitute legal advice and is intended for information only. Information provided is contextual to the time it was issued and can change.
Our comprehensive analysis is typically exclusive to ETA members, but we’re making it available to all readers for a limited time.
The Federal Trade Commission’s new Click to Cancel rule brings significant changes to how businesses handle subscription and automatic renewal agreements. While many companies have focused on its consumer-facing implications, the rule also has important ramifications for B2B relationships, particularly in merchant processing agreements.
Key Changes in Contract Management
The rule draws a crucial distinction between fixed-term and auto-renewal contracts. Fixed-term agreements running for 1-3 years with regular monthly payments but no automatic renewal are likely not covered by the final rule. However, if your contract includes automatic renewal provisions that extend beyond the initial term, it falls under the rule’s jurisdiction.
Pre-Contract Disclosure Requirements
Increased transparency is the goal of the new requirements. Businesses must provide comprehensive disclosures before obtaining any billing information. This includes:
- Pricing details and automatic renewal terms
- Clear cancellation policies
- Material terms of service
For merchant processing services, while providing exact pricing may be challenging, businesses must offer ways for customers to estimate approximate costs. This represents a significant shift in how service providers must present their terms to potential clients.
Cancellation Procedures
The “Same Method” Rule
One of the most significant changes is the requirement for cancellation accessibility. The rule is relatively straightforward: customers must be able to cancel through the same channel they used to sign up. For instance, if a customer signs up online, they must have access to an online cancellation option. This applies similarly to phone sign-ups and in-person enrollments, though in-person sign-ups must also offer alternative cancellation methods such as phone or online options.
Making Cancellation Accessible
The FTC’s final rule is clear about what constitutes an acceptable cancellation process. It must be easy to find, simple to use, and free from unnecessary barriers. For online services, this means customers should be able to locate a cancellation button quickly after logging into their account. The days of hidden cancellation options or complicated multi-step processes are over.
Contract Term Considerations
Several questions remain about handling mid-term cancellations. While the rule requires businesses to provide ways to “immediately stop charges,” the implications for remaining contract obligations when a customer cancels mid-term need careful consideration. This is particularly relevant for businesses with long-term service agreements.
Implementation Challenges
The new rule necessitates significant process modifications for many businesses. Companies need to carefully review their sign-up procedures, particularly the timing of disclosures versus signature collection. Merchant applications and term sheets may need restructuring to ensure all required disclosures are made before obtaining signatures.
Customer Retention Strategies
While the rule doesn’t prohibit “save the sale” efforts, it sets clear boundaries. Businesses can still attempt to retain customers, but they must do so without creating unreasonable barriers to cancellation. This means:
- No additional steps or conditions before processing cancellation requests
- Clear and straightforward cancellation processes
- Transparent communication about cancellation options
Current Status and Legal Challenges
The rule currently faces legal challenges, with at least two lawsuits questioning the FTC’s rule-making process. While these challenges proceed through the legal system, businesses should continue preparing for compliance.
Next Steps for Businesses
Businesses should take a proactive approach to compliance by:
- Reviewing and updating automatic renewal agreements
- Redesigning disclosure timing and content
- Streamlining cancellation processes
- Implementing accessible online cancellation options where appropriate
- Training staff on new requirements
- Monitoring ongoing legal developments
While some aspects of the rule’s implementation remain unclear, businesses should focus on areas where requirements are well-defined. The emphasis should be on transparency in disclosures and creating straightforward cancellation processes that align with the rule’s requirements.
What’s Next: The rule is set to be enforced starting March 31, 2025. A lawsuit has been filed, challenging the FTC’s authority to issue the rule. The incoming Trump Admiration and 119th Congress may alter or rollback the rule.
Remember that these changes affect not just consumer-facing operations but also B2B relationships, requiring careful consideration of how existing business practices may need to evolve to meet new compliance standards.